13 Allahabad High Court Judges Write to Chief Justice, Objecting to Supreme Court Order. Matter Related to Judicial Independence and Constitutional Values.
Allahabad HC: The Supreme Court has removed two paragraphs from an order issued on August 4, 2025. These paragraphs pertained to barring Justice Prashant Kumar of the Allahabad High Court from hearing criminal cases. The Supreme Court issued this order after Justice Kumar made a comment justifying criminal proceedings in a civil dispute, which drew the Court's displeasure.
Objection of High Court Judges
Regarding this decision, all 13 current judges of the Allahabad High Court have written to the Chief Justice. The letter appeals for the non-implementation of the Supreme Court's order. The judges state that this order affects judicial independence and constitutional balance.
What the Letter States
The High Court judges have demanded that a Full Court meeting be convened on this matter. They argue that the Supreme Court's order not only challenges constitutional values but also directly interferes with the functioning of the High Court. According to the judges, making such a decision regarding the work style of a single judge can affect the independence of the entire institution.
What Was the Original Supreme Court Order?
In its August 4th order, the Supreme Court criticized Justice Prashant Kumar, stating that he wrongly upheld criminal proceedings in a civil matter. The Court also stated that irregularities were observed in the process of granting bail. Based on this, instructions were given to remove him from hearing criminal cases.
Justice Pardiwala's Comment
Justice J.B. Pardiwala, included in the Supreme Court bench, wrote in his order, "The court must first understand the seriousness of the subject, and then deliver a verdict according to the law, keeping in mind the plaintiff's arguments." He further stated that the High Court's order was not only legally incorrect but also a serious oversight of jurisprudence.
Why is the Allahabad High Court's Reaction Important?
The Allahabad High Court is one of the largest and oldest High Courts in India. The collective writing of a letter by its judges against an order is a significant event in judicial history. This step demonstrates that differences between the Supreme Court and the High Court regarding working methods and jurisdiction are deepening.
